web analytics
Login
Subscribe
Breaking News         Sugarbush KC     08/22/2014     Best In Show Judge: Mr. Jay Richardson     Best In Show: GCH Byrequest Bon Mot     Southern Indiana KC     08/22/2014     Best In Show Judge: Mr. Pete Dawkins     Best In Show: GCH Stonepillars Steel Blu     Northwestern Connecticut DC     08/22/2014     Best In Show Judge: Mr. Robert Stein     Best In Show: GCH Mcvans To Russia With Love     Topeka KC     08/22/2014     Best In Show Judge: Mrs. Patricia Trotter     Best In Show: GCH Dawin Hearts On Fire     Sawnee Mountain KC of Georgia     08/22/2014     Best In Show Judge: Ms. Sharon Lyons     Best In Show: GCH Riverside Telltail Coco Posh     Destination – Herding Dog Advisory Council To Wind Down The growing problem of canine dementia White Swiss Shepherds 2014 American Kennel Club Breeder of the Year Award Group Honorees Named

We'll email you the stories that fanciers want to read from all around the web daily

We don't share your email address

With Homeopathy, ‘Like Cures Like’

Homeopathy just might be the dark horse of nontraditional, or complementary, veterinary care. Its basic concept can be difficult for the uninitiated to even grasp, let alone consider as viable. But its advocates – both practitioners and beneficiaries – can’t imagine helping dogs and other animals to good health without it.

It involves administering a remedy under the premise that “like cures like,” a method developed at the turn of the 19th century by Samuel Hahnemann. Manufacturers of remedies take a particular element, dilute it in water or alcohol, then agitate the mixture in a procedure called “succussion.” During succussion, the element’s basic value is transmitted to the water or alcohol.

One practitioner whose treatment centers on homeopathy is Ann Swartz, D.V.M., C.V.H. She’s also the president of the Academy of Veterinary Homeopathy, an organization of veterinarians who have established a certain standard of care, accredit courses in the practice and also certify veterinarians in homeopathy, thus the “C.V.H.” – certified veterinary homeopath – behind her name. “Our goal is to convey that certified members have a certain area of expertise in practicing classical homeopathy,” she says. By “classical,” she means the way Hahnemann practiced – using just one remedy at a time, then monitoring its effectiveness.

Homeopathy is an often misunderstood term, let alone treatment. “Most frequently, someone will say, ‘I want homeopathy’ or ‘I’ve tried homeopathy.’ What they’ve tried is a vitamin or an herb. People confuse all the ‘h’ words: herbal, holistic, homeopathy.”

She likely did the same back before she got her veterinary degree from Oregon State University in 1988. Nonetheless, her goal “even when I came right out of vet school,” as it is now, is “to provide at least three choices for a client to choose what might work best in their management situation, their home life and their own philosophy. It’s more like a team approach.”

While she lays out for clients what treatment conventional veterinary medicine would indicate, at this point in her practice, many seek her out because she is a veterinary homeopath.

“A lot of the cases we see come to us because the individual might be sensitive or oversensitive to medication. They can’t take the conventional medication that the veterinarian is prescribing. Some owners choose not to do surgery or can’t afford a treatment,” she says. Sometimes the animal is resistant to the normal drugs prescribed for a condition. Oftentimes, the animals – Swartz’ practice is about half large and half small animal – have unusual symptoms or exhibit unusual behaviors. “I can remember being a conventional practitioner and not knowing what to do for those things.”

Swartz says that veterinary homeopaths “all have lots of stories” of their patients’ recoveries after receiving the right remedy, and shares one of her own that is “so exciting,” she says.

“I first saw a puppy Chi mix when he was 4 months old. Since 10 weeks of age, he had been on antibiotics, steroids and antihistamines for a respiratory problem.” Nonetheless, the puppy still had “fluid lung sounds” and was “not feeling very well. It took a while to talk about everything that had happened, the progression, getting a timeline of cause and effect, and the inter-relationship of the whole thing. In the history, eventually, it was sort of teased out that it had been chilled numerous times as a baby.”

Homeopathic remedies often come in a liquid form, which is easy to administer. Photo © Can Stock Photo

Swartz gave the puppy a remedy of aconitum, which is for any kind of ill effect from a chill. She asked the owner to call her the next day to let her know how the puppy was doing. “In the next day or two, the puppy was feeling great,” she says, and was able to be taken off the drugs. “For the first time, this puppy was on no medications. That’s pretty dramatic, and, no doubt, the recovery was due to the remedy.”

She’s seen the same thing in lambs. They’re a couple of days or a week old and have pneumonia, she says. “In my previous life [as a traditional veterinarian], I would have had them on antibiotic injections twice a day, and many would have died. One or two doses of aconitum and they recover. So, that’s a really nice remedy.”

Homeopathic remedies are made from “any number of substances,” and most are given as a liquid or pellet. However, she says, “The form of the remedy doesn’t so much matter. The amount doesn’t always so much matter. It’s the potency.”

Potency is described by a “c” or centesimal scale, such that a 30c remedy, for example, is less diluted with fewer succusses and less potent than a 200c remedy. “The sicker the animal, the lower the potency” used, Swartz says.

Most practitioners buy remedies from pharmacies. The remedies are “regulated by the USDA [United States Department of Agriculture], so there’s quality control and inspections,” she says, just as there are with any over-the-counter medication.

Homeopathic treatment is first about getting to the bottom of the condition, then prescribing the right remedy and monitoring the animal’s response. “That’s what makes the practice a little more follow-up, paying a little more attention to what the individual does” after the remedy is administered.

While “anything can be treated with homeopathy,” Swartz says, “there are a number of things in this life that can’t be cured no matter what you do. There are still things no matter what modality you use that are really bad,” such as skin issues, autoimmune conditions and “system” problems, those that involve an entire body system, rather than a single part.

“When someone comes to me, if they want to do homeopathy, we talk about what is involved and what it entails. The goal is the comfort of the both the patient and the client. I guess in my practice, I try not to judge people for their choices.”

Although Swartz’ practice is centered on homeopathy, she happily refers clients to practitioners of other types of treatment, including traditional, even aggressive, veterinary medicine. Photo © Can Stock Photo

That means if a dog owner wants to try Chinese medicine, Swartz refers him or her to someone she knows and trusts. That includes “conventional, aggressive therapy,” if that’s the route the person chooses. What she would like to see is her “conventional colleagues” refer their clients, who want to try something different or for whom conventional veterinary treatment isn’t working, to homeopathy practitioners. “I would hope that we’re getting closer to that in the MD world as well as in the DVM world.”

Many other non-traditional treatments, such as chiropractic, acupuncture and herbs, have long been accepted as aids in the treatment of a variety of animal illnesses. That acceptance in the United States goes back a few decades, however many of the treatments hearken to ancient times in other parts of the world.

Homeopathy is still finding its way in this country, as evidenced by a resolution from the Connecticut Veterinary Medical Association presented to the January 2013 American Veterinary Medical Association //Link “American Veterinary Medical Association” to https://www.avma.org/Pages/home.aspx //meeting in Chicago which sought to label the treatment ineffective and not recommended. Despite the resolution, “We were very pleasantly surprised by our reception on a personal level, very pleased with the discussion, also about other complementary treatments.” Representatives of the American Holistic Veterinary Medical Association //link “American Holistic Veterinary Medical Association” to http://www.ahvma.org/ //were also on hand at the meeting.

Acceptance in the veterinary community, Swartz says, “depends on where you are. I think a lot of that is client-driven. Or veterinarians are seeing and realizing that conventional therapy is not working, and that it might be helpful for their own clients. If you’re in a more alternative-minded area, where there are more naturopathic practitioners in the human field, food co-ops and organic growers, the veterinarians are going to tend to think more about alternative therapies. Veterinarians and MDs are all trying to do what’s best for their patients.”

She estimates that acceptance likely ranges from 0 to 100 percent, “depending on where you are.” And, while the relationship between conventional veterinarians and homeopathy veterinarians might seem “adversarial,” she thinks that might be “because we see each others’ cases that aren’t going well.”

The resolution is now making its way through the normal AVMA channels for review and consideration.

“The whole discussion has been wonderful for homeopathy in general, opening a whole new avenue of discussion with our colleagues,” Swartz says, adding that “most veterinarians don’t really know what homeopathy is.”

Researchers are working to scientifically prove that homeopathy works, but Swartz says she knows it does, “having seen things happen and having good outcomes. But a lot of people are interested in proving it. What we’re finding now in research related to particle physics is that there are tiny, tiny little particles [of the element that remain in the water or alcohol] – nanoparticles – that we have not been able to measure. I think there’s something coming down the pike on that.”

In the meantime, animal owners continue to seek out Swartz’ expertise, and she, along with other certified veterinary homeopaths, continues to put homeopathy to work on behalf of those people’s pets and other animals.

Written by

Susan Chaney has been on the editorial side of publishing since 1990, starting her career as a newspaper features writer and editor. A lifelong lover of dogs, Susan has lived with German Shepherds, Labs, Yorkies, an Irish Setter, a Great Dane-Bloodhound mix, a Sheltie and currently a Chihuahua mix of unknown pedigree. She was the editor of Dog Fancy magazine, content editor of DogChannel.com and group editor of Dog World, Dogs USA, Puppies USA, Natural Dog, Cat Fancy, Cats USA and Kittens USA from March 2005 to December 2009 when she left her position to work at home, part-time. Susan lives in Long Beach, Calif., with her artist husband, Tim, that Chi mix and two big cats. As an editor and writer for Best In Show Daily, she is reveling in the amalgam of three loves: writing, editing and dogs.
Comments
  • Cindy Cooke April 16, 2013 at 9:37 AM

    The August 27, 2005 issue of the Lancet, the premier British medical journal, considered more than 200 clinical trials comparing the effects of homeopathic remedies to conventional medicine. You can read the conclusion here: http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(05)67177-2/abstract. There is no scientific evidence to support homeopathy. I am astonished that anyone with even a rudimentary knowledge of science (I include myself in that category) would consider homeopathy as a viable medical or veterinary treatment. When the proponents of this quackery can bring some evidence to the table, I will rethink my position, but until then, my response to the “like cures like” theory is: HORSEFEATHERS! (See book of the same title by Dr. David Ramey, DVM, or any of his other writings). I’ll end with some words from Dr. Ramey: “There is effective medicine and ineffective medicine. There is no alternative to that which works. There is no ‘alternative’ form of airplane engineering or colic surgery, In an effort to promote their own therapies, alternative-therapy practitioners often mischaracterize medicine and imply that there is an alternative to proven, effective vaccines, drugs, and treatment methods.” (See complete article at http://www.thehorse.com/articles/10138/alternative-therapies-quality-or-quackery)

    • Susan Chaney
      Susan Chaney April 17, 2013 at 8:56 AM

      Thank you, Cindy, for bringing a different perspective to this topic. As I mentioned in the article, homeopathy might be called the “dark horse” of complementary veterinary medicine. I, personally, prefer to see studies that scientifically support such treatments, however when Doctors of Veterinary Medicine practice using something that they say works, I have to keep the possibility open…

      I hope more readers will chime in on what they think about this topic.

    • Lisa Brienen, DVM, CVH April 18, 2013 at 2:23 PM

      Hello Cindy, I have been in veterinary practice since 1992, and using homeopathy for my patients since 1996. It probably helps to have a wonderful healing effect yourself or know someone with a great testimonial to understand the true potential of homeopathy. From a personal stand point, I am grateful to homeopathy for healing my eczema. Before homeopathy, for over 20 years, I was completely reliant on steroid creams to keep the rashes from all over my hands, my arms, behind my ears and around my eyelids. The healing process was gradual – 2 years before I was free from eczema. I’ve not used a steroid cream since 1995. The great benefit of homeopathy though was it didn’t just heal my skin. I soon had regular and stress free menstrual cycles, better digestion and anxieties and depressions were incredibly improved.
      I have had many interesting and wonderful cases over the years, but one that frequently stands out was one of my earliest patients, my own 17 year old Retriever mix, Samson. One day I noticed that he was suddenly blind and was circling around the yard like crazy. I examined him and he definitely could not see. I wondered if he’d had a stroke and he was so wild I wasn’t sure how to even get him into the car to take him to my clinic. I decided to try a remedy which matched my dog’s symptoms, called Belladonna. I managed to hold him long enough to get the pellets into his mouth. After just a few minutes he calmed down and started looking around and “seeing” me. He was fine after that. I’ve had several more experiences with rapid and specific responses to homeopathic remedies in emergencies, but this was one of my first experiences that compelled me that homeopathy works. When I first started veterinary practice, like you, I was a skeptic about anything holistic. There were just so many cases though that exhausted the offerings of conventional medicine. I searched for a modality to fill the gap and found homeopathy. Sincerely, Lisa Brienen DVM, CVH

  • Tim Bulone April 17, 2013 at 9:14 AM

    I honestly believe that if homeopathic remedies were truly unfounded vets would discontinue their use (if only to avoid liability) and yet those who include them in their practice do not. I submit that scientific knowledge may only be a subset of ALL knowledge and not synonymous with it, but that is just the mystic in me talking.

  • Shelley Epstein, VMD, CVH April 18, 2013 at 7:27 AM

    Cindy,

    I am a practicing veterinarian and owner of an AAHA-accredited practice. We offer our clients a variety of options, conventional as well as complementary and alternative. My particular area of expertise is homeopathy which I’ve been using since 1995. I can assure you that if it didn’t work, I would have abandoned it long ago, just like many other therapies I’ve seen come and go in my 28 years of practice.

    Your post highlights the kind of misinformation campaign that homeopathy has been subjected to. For example, it is interesting that of the 6 meta-analyses published since 1991, you chose the only one that claimed homeopathy to be ineffective. And that particular study was highly criticized as failing to meet The Lancet’s own QUOROM statement (Quality of Reports of Meta-analyses of Randomised Controlled Trials) that had been published in The Lancet in 1999. Further, while that study may have “considered” 110 (not over 200 as you state) clinical trials, it selected only 8 for the final analysis, enabling statistical manipulations to achieve their desired results.

    I would encourage readers to visit the Academy of Veterinary Homeopathy’s
    webpage:http://www.theavh.org/avma/index.html

    and click on “AVH Homeopathy White Paper.” For anybody interested in the science behind homeopathy- and this is a rapidly growing field- you can read a summary here. This paper was written in response to the one-sided white paper submitted by the Connecticut VMA to the AVMA. I was one of the authors.

  • Post a comment